PeerTube, an alternative to YouTube?

Honestly, unless PeerTube instances start actually moderating their content, they will just be a cess pit of far right material. Every instance I have seen, had a ton of far right content. No thanks.

2 Likes

How many “instances” are there? How many did you review? What is stopping you, in true mentality of the co-operative movement, to maintain and moderate an instance that excludes “a ton of far right content”? There are mastodon servers that successfully implement their own moderation standards, without impact on the “fediverse”.

As an example of an instance subscribed to (admittedly, only one of six atom feeds in total that are subscribed):

https://scitech.video/feeds/videos.atom?sort=-trending

Where’s the “far right”? :wink:

If you’ve not come across the controversies about the problems with PeerTube project and moderation then I’d be surprised. It’s been a hot topic of discussion on the Fediverse for quite a while. Don’t gaslight me like that :+1:

Look at the front page of this instance you used for example:
https://open.tube/videos/overview

It includes a speech by proscribed terrorist group National Action. That’s actually illegal content in the UK.

Bit off topic though now.

2 Likes

Word.

For a link into the discussion, I guess https://weirder.earth/@distel/103119146368074802 will do it. This is in contrast to moves like https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2019/07/statement-on-gabs-fork-of-mastodon/.

Peertube has issues, thanks for raising this.

1 Like

It’s easy to “cherry-pick”:

scitech.video PeerTube
Welcome to scitech.video, a PeerTube server for anything technical! Power users, programmers, hackers, makers, scientists, tinkerers, radio operators, free software enthusiasts or similar may host their videos here for free as part of the Fediverse. scitech.video is strictly moderated and follows three main guidelines: * All videos and comments must be suitable for viewing by people of all ages * No commercial/sponsored content * Channels should fit the “technical” theme in some way You can contact the administrator via email (admin@scitech.video). If you are a viewer and you want to subscribe or comment you will need to create an account. Note that an account created here on scitech.video cannot look up or subscribe to content from other servers. This is a restriction to ensure scitech.video users cannot inadvertently view inappropriate content from elsewhere on the PeerTube federation. (It’s a jungle out there.)

The internet has issues, thanks for raising.

The original point: if a co-op is a legitimate alternative to big corporation entities, technology such as peertube, mastodon, etc. should be considered as a viable alternatives to the usual platform monopolists.

1 Like

There is a Mastodon instance run as a cooperative called Social Coop. I would suppose that a tool like Mastodon or PeerTube can be used for both good and bad. The concerns about the far-right utilising it are of course legitimate and with merit, but that shouldn’t mean that it shouldn’t be utilised for good purposes as well.

2 Likes

The point here to me is that platforms need to choose to develop good tools to make content moderation effective. It doesn’t happen automatically. And it seems too often the case that people who are able (technically, economically, etc) to build platforms and tools are the least aware of the need for such things.

Instead we rely on other people raising these issues, and for those more directly impacted by the content this might be an intense and emotional thing to do. And this has led to better moderation tools being implemented. But it’s hard work bringing up awareness about issues like this, it takes a lot of energy and risk of aggressive pushbacks, toxic arguments, and worse, … etc. And at the end, when/if better moderation tools are implemented, we all enjoy the fruit of that labour, and some may even wonder what all the fuss was about in the first place.

So, I thank all the people that do this awareness raising work :clap: and those that accept the need for better tooling and implement it :clap:

3 Likes

I did have a good experience with PeerTube last night when following and commenting a friend’s channel from my Mastodon account. At least that side of it is looking slick :heart:

3 Likes